Pgr3 Scores 10 Out Of 10, on 1up.com Options

[Shawn_]

awesome!

[Deftech]

lol, you might wanna post a link to the review next time.

I can't find it at the moment.

[yutaro]

It's right here
http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3145713&did=1

On launch it's either that or PDZ... I can't decide

[wasting]

and 1up gives kameo a 7? gimme a break

[stazi]

I'm pretty damn disapointed with the IGN PGR3 review

[KAGE360]

why what was wrong with the IGN review? also did any other review mention about that whole "PGR3 not really running at 720p" BS??

[ZildjianKX]

why what was wrong with the IGN review?  also did any other review mention about that whole "PGR3 not really running at 720p" BS??

No review has mentioned this yet, have they? This should at least effect how they rate the graphics...

[twistedsymphony]

No review has mentioned this yet, have they?  This should at least effect how they rate the graphics...

Should it? WHY? What difference does it make if the final product of the graphics could be considered a 10?

Thats like turning your nose up to a painting because you didn't think the brushes the painter used were high enough quality regardless of the paintings beauty...

Not to mention... was that ever substantiated? AFAIK it's still rumor...

[brooksie48]

and 1up gives kameo a 7? gimme a break

Gimme a break, have you played them both and completed them? I didn't think so, don't talk.

[tonloc79]

Over the past summer, I became a pedestrian for the first time since I turned sixteen years old.

Thats how the review starts out. No offense to young people but the opinion of a 16 year old doesnt mean sh#t to me. 10 out of 10 doesnt leave much room for improvement does it. 1up suck balls! Their reviews are useless. Have a nice day P.S. I will be getting this game and im not knocking it, im sure its GREAT i just think its funny how quick they are to hand out a 10.

This post has been edited by tonloc79: Nov 16 2005, 06:53 AM

[Arius]

No game will ever be a 10/10

Its a joke seeing scores like that, and they are usually confined to playstation mags, god forbid we are going to see every other game rated 10/10 on the xbox 360.

[mikedavis2838]

Thats how the review starts out. No offense to young people but the opinion of a 16 year old doesnt mean sh#t to me. 10 out of 10 doesnt leave much room for improvement does it. 1up suck balls! Their reviews are useless. Have a nice day

umm, I think he was saying that hasn't been a pedestrian for a long time, since he was 16 in fact. Just because i havn't been a pedestrian since i was 16, doesnt mean i am 16.

[jop12]

No game will ever be a 10/10

Its a joke seeing scores like that, and they are usually confined to playstation mags, god forbid we are going to see every other game rated 10/10 on the xbox 360.

A 10/10 could mean that they felt the game exceeded in areas where other games didnt, and i dont see how that will never happen... They could be comparing pgr3 to other games in general and how satisfying it was to them. Compared to those other games pgr3 is the best in the fields of comparison to them.

[Arius]

Its all opinions, but for me 10/10 means there will never be a better game.

I can understand your point of view, and have had the case argued in that way before with me. But I dont beleive there should ever be a 10/10 rating for any game. It just means it will never ever get better, that the game is perfection.

and as we all know there is no game that is perfect.

[jop12]

Well i thought about it... and you are probly right, But if you were then a game couldnt be a 9 or even a 8... because what if they came out with games that were slightly better than the game that scored an 8 or a 9, then they eventually would come out with a 10/10, then a 11/10 if the games kept getting better, so you cant really compare it to other games, you have to compare the rating to how the game comes together, and thats how I think they rate games... etc.