Crap. Some of us still play Smash Bros. Melee to no end, either.
Almost every game is overrated by someone, most times. It's a matter of opinion. I really dug Halo, but I'm not that great at FPS games, so the multiplayer didn't do it for me.
Tho truth be told, if we could play a 60 frames per second Perfect Dark on the Xbox, it would easily rule Halo, graphics downgrade & all.