Ok Well i played it and would rank it:
7 out of 10.
Its a solid sports game however it receives a 7 due to the following:
Unrealistic dropped balls: Not too often, but when it does your like what? How did he miss that catch/interception.
Players look O.K: The players look pretty good when the auto camera is swirling around them at a close view, but from the standard view (right before your about to snap the ball), the players dont look far off of PS2.
Sideline players look plain: Not a big gripe, but players look like cheap versions of those on the field. Note* Not a big gripe, but I would have thought the 360 would have been able to handle these sideline graphics.
Im basically just nit-picking at the game. Its overall feel is smooth and commentating is damn near perfect. I just hope Madden incorporates some of these commenting skills.
My vote would be to get the game if your even a slight college football fan. This post has been edited by _Hines_: Jul 18 2006, 11:59 PM