FOR ME.. personally.. an Mp3 player is an Mp3 player is an Mp3 player.. I recently sold my old black Zune on eBay and got one of the Halo 3 zunes. It works fine for me.. plays my videos and mp3s. I'm glad it's getting the 2.1 fw, but i'm still going to use it just the same... nano, ipod.. zune.. what the hell ever.. whatever floats your boat, ultimately, don't they all do the EXACT SAME THING? And with the recent price drop, who can complain, or why complain ?