QUOTE
i hope there are at least monsters n stuff.
Sorry, avatars are rated E so's when children look at your profile it doesn't scare or offend them. Also so the avatars can appear in games without changing the rating.
QUOTE
You can ... just use your gamerpic
No you can't, that's what this whole release is about. So that their awesome friends page will actually have some avatars in it, they're forcing you to make one, which will be pushed to anyone that looks at your LIVE account from the NXE dashboard.
QUOTE
why could they not just assign you a default shadow of an avatar if you chose to not create one
Because if there was a default avatar, everyone that didn't want one would use it. By making you choose from a selection of randomly-generated ones, it's not obvious whether you're looking at one that was lovingly hand-selected like all the fanboys in the videos did, or was the result of someone mashing A so's the thing would fuck off and let him play his game.
QUOTE(seanhassars @ Oct 10 2008, 09:08 PM)

seriously people, who cares if you have to pick an avatar. if you're really that worried about it, maybe you need to take a little break from the xbox and get your priorities straight. as long as it's still going to play your games who cares?
Because there doesn't appear to be any way to play your games (assuming you're interested in online play; if you're not, sell your 360 and get a DS) without having a stupid cartoon representing yourself to the world. Even if you don't ever look at it, it's there conveying to other people an impression you don't want to convey. It's like someone forcing you to wear a Power Rangers shirt at all times.
I think anyone considering something like this would do well to consider video phones. Any phone you buy nowadays can do video calling. But no-one uses it. Because the attraction of making a phone call is that the person you're calling
can't see you. The whole reason SMS is so popular is because it lets you converse without having to deal with another person in realtime.
Look at the gamercards of anyone you see playing Halo: do they tell you anything about themselves in the profile fields? No, they certainly don't: the profile is either empty, or used for slogans or jokes. The fields in the profile act ually end up being used based on where they appeared on the gamercard, not what their labels said they were for. This should be a clear sign that LIVE users want
less imposition of intimacy, not more.
Nintendo had the right idea with the miis: they're not 'your' mii, they're just one of tens of little computer people that live in your wii. Your miis go and visit your friends' wiis, and just kinda appear in the games. You can have miis that you consider 'yours', but the console has nothing to do with that. It certainly doesn't scream to the world HAY ?HERE@S THIS GUYS INTERNET SELF LOOK.
Also, all the avatars look like that bell-end off the Mac adverts.